Best Wedding Cakes in Kentucky, KY

Heitzman Bakery is a bakery that has been serving Louisville for over 12 decades. They offer classic wedding cake flavors, including yellow, Italian, strawberry, cherry, and red velvet. Their services also include buttercream and fondant designs as well as a variety of cake shapes. Delivery is available for a small fee. You can also send the team photos of cakes that inspire you so that they have an idea of your tastes and preferences for the design of your cake.

Address: 3333 Bardstown Road Louisville, KY 40218

Phone: 502-452-1891

Social: Facebook

Sweets by Millie is a wedding cake bakery with a collection of accolades from renowned national publications. They have a history of providing clients with custom cakes that are as delectable as they are decorative. Tastings and consultations are available by appointment for a small fee. 

The team at Sweets by Millie requests that custom cake orders be placed at least six months in advance to ensure that every detail and specification is attended to. The flavors they offer are virtually limitless, from brown sugar pound cake to banana-pecan. Their fillings include bourbon buttercream, lime cream cheese, and lemon curd. Custom cookies and cupcakes are available by request as well, for a twist on the classic wedding cake.

Address: 223 S Hancock Street, Louisville, KY 40202

Phone: 502-488-8312

Social: Instagram

Sugar Fashion Cakes is a wedding cake bakery run by professional pastry chef Sarah Roberts, who has a number of awards from prominent TV networks and publications. When it comes to her custom wedding cakes, she can cook up flavors including mocha latte, snickerdoodle, and Bailey’s Irish cream. 

Sugar Fashion Cakes also offers a number of fillings, including Bavarian cream, chocolate ganache, and chai tea buttercream. Pricing is modeled on a sliding scale according to the size of the client’s guest list, and local delivery is offered for a small fee. Sarah recommends that cake bookings be made 2-3 months in advance of the wedding date.

Address: Okolona Louisville, KY 40219

Phone: 270-234-8043

Social: Facebook | Instagram

The Mischief Maker, based in Lexington, Kentucky, is renowned for creating one-of-a-kind wedding cakes that are as visually stunning as they are delicious. Alex Narramore, the creative force behind the business, is a self-taught baker and botanically accurate sugar flower artist. Each cake is a masterpiece, adorned with meticulously hand-sculpted sugar flowers crafted from specimens grown in Alex’s own garden. Mischief Maker’s dedication to customization, high-quality ingredients, and intricate detailing ensures that every cake is a work of art. The business takes on only a few clients, focusing on delivering exceptional results that exceed expectations, with each cake designed exclusively for that couple’s special day and never recreated.

Address: Lexington, KY

Phone: 859 537 3581

Social: Facebook | Instagram

Located in downtown Lexington, Martine’s Pastries has been delighting customers since 1999. Owned by Martine and Jim Holzman, this bakery, café, and cake shop is known for its exquisite wedding cakes and pastries. Each cake is a masterpiece, featuring rich yet delicate buttercream frosting made from the finest ingredients, including real butter and premium European chocolates. Martine’s philosophy emphasizes excellent customer service and artisanal craftsmanship, ensuring that every dessert is not only delicious but also an unforgettable experience. Their wide variety of flavors caters to all tastes, making it easy for couples to find the perfect cake for their special day. At Martine’s Pastries, love is baked from scratch, creating sweet memories for every celebration.

Address: 400 E Third St Lexington, KY 40508

Phone: 859-231-9110

Social: Facebook | Instagram

Founded by Chef Cameron and Tracie in 2005, Tinker’s Cake Shop has been a beloved specialty cake shop in Lexington, known for creating stunning wedding cakes that not only look beautiful but taste incredible. After meeting in culinary school, the couple combined their passion for baking to craft made-from-scratch cakes that have won numerous awards over the years. Committed to quality, each cake is made fresh without ever being frozen, ensuring a delightful experience for couples on their special day. Tinker’s Cake Shop focuses on personalized service, working closely with clients to design cakes that reflect their unique style and vision. Every cake from Tinker’s is a true labor of love, making it a perfect choice for couples seeking a memorable wedding cake.

Address: 317 W Maxwell St Lexington, KY 40508

Phone: 859-252-9636

Social: Facebook | Instagram