6 Best Wedding Cake Bakers in Long Island, NY

Audrey’s Fine Baked Goods, nestled in the heart of West Sayville, has been crafting delectable wedding cakes since 1996. Their on-premise bakery ensures every cake is freshly made, offering a plethora of flavors and designs to suit any couple’s dream celebration. Renowned for their impeccable quality and personalized service, Audrey’s caters to various venues and businesses across Long Island and the New York tri-state area. Whether it’s an extravagant affair or an intimate gathering, Audrey’s expert decorators turn visions into reality, ensuring each cake is a sweet finale to a magical day. With a reputation built on passion and talent, Audrey’s Fine Baked Goods promises stress-free cake planning and unforgettable results.

Address: 229-231 Montauk Highway, West Sayville, NY 11796

Phone: 631-244-7288

Social: Facebook | Instagram

With over 30 years of baking expertise, Francesco’s Bakery brings a touch of tradition and a wealth of experience to every cake they create. Established in 1986 in Hicksville, New York, their commitment to customer satisfaction shines through in every custom creation. From whimsical designs inspired by favorite cartoons to elegant wedding masterpieces, Francesco’s team is dedicated to bringing their clients’ sweetest dreams to life. Using only the finest ingredients, their old-fashioned baking methods ensure each cake is fresh, delicious, and tailored to perfection. For residents of Hicksville and beyond, Francesco’s Bakery is the go-to destination for custom pastries and delectable treats that add a memorable touch to any occasion.

Address: 640 S Broadway, Hicksville, NY 11801

Phone: 516-931-6822

Social: Facebook | Instagram

Celebrate your special day with a masterpiece from one of Long Island’s most esteemed wedding cake creators. Beginning its journey in 1959, this bakery has evolved into a top choice for couples seeking stunning, delicious cakes for their wedding. Offering personalized tastings and consultations, they ensure each cake is a reflection of the couple’s dream. From sampling fillings and icings to receiving a sketch of your envisioned cake, they are dedicated to making your dessert experience unforgettable. Renowned for their exquisite designs and delectable taste, their cakes not only captivate visually but also delight the palate. Highly recommended by prestigious party halls and banquet facilities, choosing them means ensuring your wedding cake is in expert hands, promising quality that’s unmatched in the region.

Address: Brentwood, NY

Phone: 631-273-7959

Social: Facebook | Instagram

Nestled in Lynbrook on Atlantic Avenue, this boutique bakery has been crafting specialty cakes and delightful sweet treats since 2010. Renowned for its commitment to safety, it proudly operates as a facility free from peanuts, tree nuts, poppy, and sesame seeds. Emphasizing customization, it invites patrons to design their dream cakes through personal appointments. Beyond cakes, the bakery offers a variety of handmade desserts including cupcakes, doughnuts, and cookies, all crafted from scratch with the highest quality ingredients. Catering to a range of dietary needs, options include low-sugar, gluten-free, vegan, and allergy-friendly choices. With a passionate team led by Chef Allison, they ensure every order is a masterpiece of edible art, perfect for any occasion from grand celebrations to intimate gatherings.

Address: 26A Atlantic Ave, Lynbrook, NY 11563

Phone: 516-596-2253

Social: Facebook | Instagram

Bringing over six decades of baking tradition, this cherished establishment offers a slice of Italy with its luscious, homemade cakes. Founded by Aniello Zambrano, a Salerno native who discovered his baking passion at just nine years old, the shop promises an authentic Italian sensory experience. With a commitment to sharing their love for outrageously delicious cakes, they now extend their family’s warmth to your doorstep, offering gourmet cakes for shipping nationwide. Each creation is a testament to a dream realized, blending rich flavors and creamy textures that evoke the essence of Italy. Ideal for any celebration, their cakes are a heartfelt invitation to taste tradition and excellence, all crafted with love from their family to yours.

Address: 4510 sunrise Hwy. Oakdale, NY 11769

Phone: 631-319-1474

Social: Facebook | Instagram

Located in Plainview and serving the Long Island and New York City Metro area, this destination is renowned for its award-winning desserts. Known for creating wedding cakes and gourmet sweets both wholesale and retail, they boast a unique selection that’s often imitated but never duplicated. Their bakery delights are crafted entirely from scratch, using only the finest ingredients like Belgian chocolate, European butter, and Tahitian vanilla beans. Offering a range of exquisite confections from one-of-a-kind pastries and specialty cakes to French Macarons and their signature Karma Kups, each dessert is a testament to innovation and quality. Their commitment to excellence and personalized service makes them a top choice for those seeking an extraordinary cake experience for their wedding.

Address: 136 Manetto Hill Rd, Plainview, NY 11803

Phone: 516-794-4478

Social: Facebook | Instagram